Judicial Economy or Judicial Convenience?
Last week, I appeared in New York County Supreme Court for a conference concerning a plaintiff’s motion for summary judgment.
I won’t identify the judge or the particular case, for reasons that should be fairly obvious. But the experience was incredibly frustrating, and it highlights something I’ve observed repeatedly throughout my years practicing law: the court’s idea of efficiency and the practical realities of litigation are not always aligned.
Sometimes, they are completely at odds.
The motion had been pending for approximately six months without a decision. The underlying claims were relatively straightforward. My opposition (representing the Defendant) was limited, and I was well aware of its weaknesses. To make matters more difficult, my client had become largely unresponsive, which, unfortunately, is not an uncommon occurrence in these MCA litigation matters.
Now, I have no problem acknowledging when a case has reached a point where there is little more to accomplish through continued litigation. My job is to advocate for my client, not to manufacture disputes, unnecessarily prolong proceedings, or create obstacles simply for the sake of creating them.
In this particular matter, opposing counsel was also quite reasonable. He’s an attorney I’ve dealt with on numerous occasions, and although we regularly find ourselves on opposite sides of disputes, I’ve generally found him to be professional, ethical, and practical. He was willing to waive certain contractual fees, including legal fees and default-related charges, which largely addressed the concerns raised in my incredibly limited opposition.
In other words, there really wasn’t much left to fight about. Except, of course, the court still had to do something. Anything really. Anything at all. And that’s where things became interesting.
During the conference, the court’s clerk repeatedly asked why the parties couldn’t settle the case.
I explained that my client was not in a position to settle. Perhaps the client lacked the money. The client simply wasn’t communicating. Either way, I couldn’t manufacture a settlement where there was no client authorization or practical ability to reach one.
The question was asked again.
I explained again.
And then a third time.
Finally, the clerk asked me what I wanted the court to do. My response was straightforward, more so than he or the Judge may be accustomed to hearing:
“I want the court to do what courts are supposed to do. Render a decision.”
Apparently, that wasn’t the answer anyone wanted to hear. No loves “do your damn job already”. The judge became involved and was audibly unhappy with my response and, I suppose, my attitude. That’s fine. I’m an acquired taste for some. Funny enough my adversary in this case would vouch for that. He’s a big fan now.
But here’s the thing: I wasn’t asking the court to do anything extraordinary. I wasn’t demanding a favorable outcome. I wasn’t asking the court to overlook the law, disregard the facts, or bend the rules in my client’s favor. I was simply asking the court to decide a motion that had been pending for approximately six months. A motion that would almost certainly be decided in favor of my adversary. That’s it.
And perhaps this is where my views differ from those of some judges.
Settlement is an important part of litigation. But settlement is not the purpose of the judiciary. The resolution of disputes is.
Sometimes that resolution comes through settlement. Sometimes it comes through mediation. Sometimes it comes through a motion or a trial. But when settlement isn’t possible, repeatedly asking why the parties can’t settle doesn’t accomplish anything. It’s even less productive when a Judge threatens me to settle a case. I have to laugh because what are you, as a judge, going to do if we (meaning me and my client) don’t come to the table to negotiate in good faith? Sanction me? Sanction my client? Good luck with that! The Courts cannot force anyone to settle. And, holding a case hostage until the parties settle a case is not only a poor use of everyone’s time but it’s, in my view, incredibly unethical. It’s like forcing a confession from someone through torture.
It doesn’t move the case forward. It doesn’t serve the litigants. And it certainly doesn’t promote judicial economy. In fact, it does precisely the opposite.
Courts frequently speak about judicial economy, efficiency, and the importance of moving cases along. Don’t waste the Court’s time! God forbid! And those are all worthwhile objectives. But judicial economy should not be confused with judicial convenience.
I don’t work for the Judge. They are servants to the people. I’m an advocate and servant to my client.
There is a meaningful difference between encouraging parties to resolve a dispute voluntarily and attempting to avoid rendering a decision because settlement would be easier for the court. Judges have difficult jobs. Their calendars are crowded, their caseloads are substantial, and the demands placed upon them are significant. I recognize all of that. I can hear the faint sounds of the world’s tiniest violin playing. They signed up for the job. They ran a campaign to get elected to their current position. They applied to be a Judge and act as servant of justice and a servant to the people.
But attorneys have difficult jobs, too. So do our clients. And my clients are often small-business owners who are already dealing with substantial financial and operational pressures. They deserve decisions, even when those decisions are unfavorable.
I have also encountered judges who apply considerable pressure on parties and their attorneys to settle. Some of that pressure is understandable. Some of it is productive. And some of it, quite frankly, is entirely misplaced. A judge can encourage settlement. A judge can facilitate meaningful discussions. A judge can help parties evaluate their respective risks and the practical consequences of continuing litigation. But a judge cannot create money that doesn’t exist. Nor can a judge create client consent where none has been given. To that end, I don’t have any obligation to force my client to give me any meaningful settlement authority no matter what the Court demands.
And threatening or chastising an attorney because a case hasn’t settled does not change those realities. Interestingly, after all of this, opposing counsel and I were able to work out a procedural resolution that would permit the entry of judgment, subject to the court’s approval.
We did so without any meaningful assistance from the court. Which brings me back to the larger point.
What exactly was accomplished by allowing a relatively straightforward motion to remain undecided for six months, only to conduct a conference focused on a settlement that wasn’t possible?
How much judicial time was consumed? How much attorney time was wasted? How much unnecessary expense was created? And for what?
I certainly don’t believe that every motion should be decided immediately. Courts must carefully consider the record, the applicable law, and the rights of the parties. Thoroughness matters. Thoughtful judicial decision-making matters. But there is a difference between thoughtful deliberation and unnecessary delay.
There is also a difference between a productive settlement conference and a repetitive exercise in pressuring parties to accomplish something that simply isn’t feasible. I know judges who conduct extraordinary settlement conferences. They are thoughtful, prepared, creative, and genuinely invested in finding practical solutions. In fact, there’s one particular judge whose approach I admire so much that I intend to write separately about her methods in a separate post.
But this isn’t an argument against judicial involvement in settlement. Quite the contrary. It’s an argument for meaningful judicial involvement, whether that means facilitating productive settlement discussions or simply deciding the motion that’s been sitting on the court’s desk.
At the end of the day, the judiciary exists to resolve disputes, not merely to encourage everyone else to resolve them. And sometimes, the most efficient thing a court can do is the job they’re hired to perform: Make a decision.
One final point here…
Sometimes I may rub certain people the wrong way, especially in the context of litigation. I try to lead every day and every moment with peace, compassion and love. But also sometimes people need a very real reminder of their place, my role, and the stage on which we stand. One can be a warrior in a garden. Not everything needs to be a battle field.
